Salem Witch Trials: Witchfinder Roger Toothaker and His Family

Written by

Show Notes

The Toothaker Family: Folk Magic, Witchfinding, and Tragedy in the Salem Witch Trials

A folk healer known as “Dr. Toothaker,” Roger Toothaker was the only male healer/physician accused of witchcraft in 17th-century New England, and his story pulls our Salem Witch Trials podcast into a web of witchfinding, fear, and family fallout. After leaving his wife Mary Allen Toothaker and their children behind in Billerica, Roger was arrested in May 1692 for allegedly afflicting Salem Village girls and died in Boston jail; testimony linked him to diagnosing victims under an “evil hand” and to a “witch bottle” said to kill a witch. Soon Mary Toothaker and their young daughter Margaret were accused, and daughter Martha Toothaker Emerson was jailed after dramatic examinations and spectral allegations, while son Allen testified against aunt Martha Carrier. Though Mary and Martha were ultimately cleared, war violence later killed Mary and took Margaret captive, underscoring how folk magic, Andover/Salem Village accusations, and ties to Carrier made the Toothakers prime targets.

Chapters

00:00 Meet the Toothakers
00:13 Roger’s Early Life
01:05 Healer Turned Accused
01:51 Testimony and Witch Bottle
03:05 Mary and Margaret Accused
04:07 Roger Dies in Jail
05:01 Martha Emerson Arrested
06:59 Specters and Confession
08:04 Mary Toothaker Confesses
09:25 Allen Testifies Against Carrier
10:20 Acquittals and Release
10:54 War and Aftermath
11:47 Legacy and Reading List